Skip to content

God and the Auditor / introduction

From distinction
to repeatable action

A reading sample from the opening of the introduction.

Text size

Six working distinctions

The following distinctions will be needed from the first pages. Each keeps its own role in the work.

Fact
An observed or documented state of affairs.
Report
What a source claims.
Hypothesis
A candidate explanation or method.
Conclusion
The result of reasoning from stated grounds.
Decision
An action chosen within the scope of authority.
Open question
A distinction for which sufficient grounds are still missing.

Adapted from the introduction, pages 6–7 of the Russian edition. The complete English translation is available in the PDF.

Two kinds of application

In the workshop, we ask: what organization should be built so that the required result can be reproduced?

In the bumblebee example, we ask: which organization of transitions best describes the observed life cycle within the chosen boundary?

In the first case, the design can change the subject itself. In the second, our model of the subject changes. This distinction is preserved throughout the stages.

Attention

What are we looking at? In designing a philosophical machine, attention is the selection of the subject that now receives computational resources.

The subject is richer than its record

A drill is sitting in the workshop. The inventory might record “one, working.” To use it in a plan, we also need its owner, the permitted uses, its period of availability, and any obligation to return it.

The subject, information about the subject, and an explanation of that information are different objects of reasoning. Inspection confirms presence. The owner’s words report the conditions. The designer’s decision determines whether those conditions are sufficient for the accepted task.

Adapted reading sample from the opening pages. The complete introduction continues in the book.

Made on
Tilda